Avail.video · Watched for you · 13:49 video · 2 min read

I Tried John Steinbeck's 6 Rules for Writing

Outlier score5.3×Overperformer

134,984 views vs a median of 25,501 across the channel's last 13 long-form uploads · as of Oct 30

Avail.video calculation

A writer experiments with John Steinbeck's famous six rules for novel writing and his daily creative rituals, evaluating how techniques like writing with 24 sharpened pencils, drafting one page at a time, and ignoring faceless audiences enhance productivity and discipline. The video explores Steinbeck's personal battles with self-doubt, his strategies for overcoming writer's block through poetry and research, and his insistence on persistence through rejection.

Read the teardown

How it earns the click and holds attention, second by second.

Find in this video

Search what was said and shown

One search covers the transcript, on-screen text, claims and references. Every result jumps to its moment.

    The explainer

    What the video says, with a link to every moment

    A 2-minute read. Each underlined phrase opens the video at that second.

    Pulitzer Prize-winning author John Steinbeck produced literary classics like East of Eden and The Grapes of Wrath, yet he struggled throughout his career with severe self-doubt and procrastination. In this video, the host tests Steinbeck’s creative habits and his six practical rules of writing. Steinbeck maintained a disciplined morning habit, beginning each session by sharpening 24 pencils at his desk0:22 and drafting by hand until all points dulled. To protect creative momentum, he followed a rule to write rapidly without editing0:42, arguing that rewriting during drafting merely provides an excuse to avoid progressing.

    quote
    “Write freely and as rapidly as possible.”John Steinbeck
    ▶ 0:43
    On screen at 0:43

    To overcome psychological friction before working on fiction, Steinbeck practiced warming up by journaling2:05, frequently penning notes about his anxieties to his editor on the left-hand pages of his manuscript notebooks. Steinbeck tackled daunting book projects by committing to abandon the idea of finishing3:58, ignoring the intimidate scale of a 400-page book and aiming strictly to finish one page per day. Despite his prolific output, Steinbeck regularly battled feelings of imposter syndrome and confessed self-doubt in his journals5:45.

    quote
    In the first place, the nameless, faceless audiencewill scare you to death and in the second place,unlike the theatre, it doesn’t exist.In writing, your audience is one single reader. Ihave found that sometimes it helps to pick out oneperson—a real person you know, or an imaginedperson and write to that one.
    ▶ 4:02
    On screen at 4:02

    A cornerstone of Steinbeck’s craft was his instruction to forget the faceless audience6:38. He reasoned that an anonymous mass of readers induces paralysis, whereas writing directly to a single reader—real or imagined—liberates the author. He learned this lesson the hard way in 1930 after attempting to write a commercial werewolf mystery for money7:32, only for it to be rejected. Through his Stanford instructor Edith Mirrielees, Steinbeck realized that great storytelling requires genuine urgency rather than commercial formula, advising authors to condense stories into one sentence10:18 before beginning.

    quote
    “I will tell them one of the greatest, perhaps thegreatest story of all - the story of good and evil, ofstrength and weakness, of love and hate, of beautyand ugliness.”John Steinbeck
    ▶ 6:44
    On screen at 6:44

    When confronting creative stagnation, Steinbeck suggested using throwaway poetry as therapy12:25 to engage musicality and rhythm without commercial pressure. Additionally, he conducted exhaustive historical research and emphasized deep personal resonance before writing. When drafting, he urged authors to bypass troublesome scenes13:49 rather than halting momentum, and to beware of overly precious scenes13:49 that stand outside the story's true rhythm. Finally, he recommended authors speak dialogue aloud13:49 to ensure natural speech cadence, urging emerging writers to accept years of rejection and slow growth13:49 as an unavoidable part of the literary craft.

    Highlights
    1. 0:22The 24-pencil ritual
    Chapters across the 13:49 runtime
    How it's told

    Explainer testing historical rules through journal demonstrations

    Format: Explainer and personal essay. The host breaks down John Steinbeck's six rules and writing habits from a study desk, contrasting his private letters with modern writing struggles. She pairs archival analysis with hands-on demonstrations in her own journal to show how shifting focus from perfection to craft transforms the creative process.

    Story arc

    1. 0:00IntroductionThe host introduces Steinbeck's six rules and his 24-pencil morning routine.
    2. 0:40Rules 1 & 2Writing freely without mid-process rewriting, and clearing the mind with morning letters or journals.
    3. 2:18Rule 3Tracking work in a writing log and abandoning the overwhelm of completing a 400-page book by focusing on one page a day.
    4. 3:37Audience & IntentExplaining why writing for one single specific person beats pleasing the abstract masses or trends.
    5. 5:16The Core LessonFormulating the story into a single sentence and learning that an effective story simply conveys a vital truth.
    6. 7:05Overcoming Writer's BlockCombating creative stagnation through throwaway poetry and immersive research.
    7. 8:31Sponsor BreakDemonstrating poetry writing and haiku composition through Skillshare courses.
    8. 10:31Rules 4, 5 & 6Bypassing difficult scenes, avoiding over-indulgence in favorite passages, and speaking dialogue aloud.
    9. 12:21ConclusionAcknowledging Steinbeck's lifetime struggle with rejection and offering encouragement to persist.

    Setups and payoffs

    1. 0:13Setup Mention of Steinbeck's rejected werewolf story Murder at Full Moon
      ↳
      4:50Payoff Full breakdown of why writing to trend for money caused Murder at Full Moon to fail
    2. 0:22Setup Displaying the twenty-four sharpened pencils ritual
      ↳
      3:16Payoff Narrator reviewing how adopting the 24-pencil ritual replaced word counts and improved her focus
    3. 5:19Setup Introducing Steinbeck's college writing teacher Edith Mirrielees
      ↳
      12:38Payoff Citing Steinbeck's 1962 letter back to Mirrielees reflecting on how her tough feedback stood the test of time
    4. 7:44Setup Steinbeck advising playwright Bob Anderson to write throwaway poetry
      ↳
      8:02Payoff Host trying out daily poetry herself to cure writer's block

    Devices

    • Kinetic Quote SlidesDisplays aged paper graphics and vintage typed quotes highlighting Steinbeck's private correspondence.0:434:027:43
    • Prop DemonstrationOverhead shots of the host actively executing Steinbeck's pencil-sharpening and journaling routines.0:221:223:16
    • Personal Experimentation NarrativeThe host tests each historical tip herself to evaluate whether it functions for modern writers.1:403:168:08
    • Direct Historical ExcerptsReading aloud from personal letters sent by Steinbeck to friends, agents, and editors.4:204:567:3312:38

    From the video's own structure, matched to the transcript and on-screen text.

    Teardown

    This video succeeds by anchoring actionable writing advice to the vulnerable private journals of a Nobel laureate, proving historical techniques through tactile desk demonstrations.

    A real overperformer: 5.3× its typical views (134,984 vs a median of 25,501 across the channel's last 13 long-form uploads, as of Oct 30) · Long-form explainer and personal essay · 9 days old

    The promise

    Viewers believe they will discover John Steinbeck's six personal writing guidelines and learn how applying them can drastically improve their own craft.

    Packaging

    How it looks in the feed

    Show the feed as
    13:49

    I tried Steinbeck’s 6 rules for writing & they transformed my writing

    MariWriting134K views · 1w agoThe first 500 people to use my link in the description will receive a one month free trial of Skillshare! https://skl.sh/mariwriting10261 I tried John…

    Views and age as of the teardown, Oct 30, 2026. Other videos are blanked out.

    • 4/5Thumbnail imageThe layout establishes clear authority by anchoring the creator's writing desk with an iconic book cover and handwritten notes. The warm, low-key lighting supports a cozy, studious mood that fits writing productivity.The creator types on a laptop between a large 'East of Eden' book cover with an arrow on the left and an open handwritten journal on the right.
    • 3/5Thumbnail text“this will transform your writing”The text is legible and bold, but it repeats the transformation promised in the title rather than adding new curiosity. At five words, it sits just above the ideal length.The phrase 'this will transform your writing' appears in white sans-serif text across the top edge.
    • 4/5TitlePairing a legendary author's name with a specific count and an experiment format creates clear value. It sets high stakes while remaining personal and grounded.The title specifies 'Steinbeck’s 6 rules for writing' and frames it around a personal trial that 'transformed my writing'.
    • 4/5Title + thumbnailThe image brings immediate literary prestige via the classic book cover while the title specifies the exact lesson and framework. Together they make a niche writing study feel essential and practical.The thumbnail visually identifies 'East of Eden' while the title defines the practical payoff as '6 rules for writing'.

    Curiosity gap: Which six specific rules did John Steinbeck rely on to craft masterpieces, and how can they fix modern writing habits?

    The three hooks

    The title, the thumbnail text and the first words spoken each make a promise, and each does a different job.

    • Title“I tried Steinbeck’s 6 rules for writing & they transformed my writing”AuthorityCuriosityProofOutcomeIt makes the viewer want to learn the proven rules of a literary master tested through a real writing routine.
    • Thumbnail text“this will transform your writing”Curiosity gapCuriosityOutcomeIt makes the viewer want to identify what specific tool or advice will dramatically upgrade their prose.
    • First words spoken“I tried John Steinbeck's 6 rules for writing, and they turned out to be some of the best advice and writing tips that I've ever heard.”ResultsCuriosityOutcomeIt promises viewers that testing Steinbeck's specific rules solved the host's writing struggles, making them want the same shortcut for their own work.
    • PairingRepeatsThe thumbnail text promises to transform writing, mirroring the title's claim that the rules transformed the creator's writing.
    • StakesFitsThe video delivers authentic excerpts from Steinbeck's private logs that directly address the universal pain of creative paralysis and self-doubt.
    • UrgencyNoneThe video relies on timeless literary craft and introspective habit-building rather than any artificial deadline or timely hook.

    The first 20 seconds

    TimeWhat you seeWhat you hearWhat it does
    0:00Overhead shot of hands writing in a journal with pencils nearby and a portrait of John Steinbeck."I tried John Steinbeck's..."Immediately visually aligns with the title about Steinbeck's writing rules.
    0:01Close-up overhead handwriting continues."...six rules for writing..."States the topic directly without any channel intro.
    0:02Torn paper graphic appears reading 'John Steinbeck's 6 rules for writing'."...and they turned out..."Reinforces the core topic with clear on-screen text.
    0:03Torn paper graphic remains centered over the notebook."...to be some of the best advice..."Sets up the bold payoff claim.
    0:04Cut to speaker talking to the camera in warm indoor lighting."...and writing tips that I've ever heard."Establishes human connection and delivers personal endorsement.
    0:05Speaker continues looking at camera.[ambient room tone / pause]Brief pacing pause before establishing historical stakes.
    0:06Speaker talking to camera."This writing advice helped him to write..."Shifts focus from personal experience to Steinbeck's credentials.
    0:07Archival photo of John Steinbeck writing in a notebook."...masterpieces..."Shows visual historical proof of Steinbeck at work.
    0:08Steinbeck archival photo held on screen."...like..."Builds anticipation for his famous titles.
    0:09Archival footage/photo of Steinbeck at a typewriter."...East of Eden..."Evokes authority through his classic literary works.
    0:10Book cover of East of Eden."...and kept him from giving up..."Introduces the emotional stakes of quitting vs perseverance.
    0:11Cover of The Grapes of Wrath appears beside East of Eden."...after..."Displays his most celebrated book covers side-by-side.
    0:12Highlighted text excerpts showing historical rejection letters appear over the covers."...countless rejections and failures..."Shows that even legendary authors faced severe rejection.
    0:13Highlighted text about rejected manuscripts remains on screen."...which..."Prepares viewer for the bridge to practical tips.
    0:14Article clipping on rejected manuscripts displayed."...leads us to the first thing..."Transitions smoothly from context into the first rule.
    0:15Cut back to speaker talking to camera."...he did."Brings focus back to the narrator to begin the list.
    0:16Speaker talks directly to camera."John Steinbeck had a unique..."Hooks curiosity about his daily process.
    0:17Text 'John Steinbeck's' appears on aged yellow parchment background."...writing ritual that he..."Signals the start of rule one with chapter title graphics.
    0:18Text 'unique writing ritual' appears beneath."...used..."Labels the first tip clearly on screen.
    0:19Title card 'John Steinbeck's unique writing ritual' centered on screen."...to write..."Confirms the first actionable chapter has begun.
    0:20Transition out of chapter title card."...every single day."Delivers the opening line of rule one.
    Click confirmation
    Instantly delivers on the title. The first frame shows a journal, pencils, and a portrait of John Steinbeck, matching the exact premise within the first second.
    Time to the point
    0:04
    Hook
    bold claim, payoff preview, stakes
    Reason to stay
    The promise to reveal the exact 6 rules that carried Steinbeck through countless rejections and drastically improved the creator's writing.
    Missing on purpose
    No channel intro animation, no greeting, no self-introduction, and no request to like or subscribe.
    Pace and texture
    Fast and purposeful. Cuts every 1 to 3 seconds between notebook footage, direct-to-camera speaking, historical photos, book covers, and title cards.

    Story map

    List. A struggling writer wants to overcome self-doubt and creative friction by adopting John Steinbeck's personal rules and daily drafting rituals, risking wasted effort if his historical methods fail in modern practice.

    TimeSectionNew tensionStakesTurnLoops
    0:00 –0:40The 24-Pencil Hook & IntroductionHow could sharpening 24 pencils every morning possibly fix writer's block?RiseSteinbeck was not being eccentric; therefore, the physical ritual created an unbroken constraint that forced rapid, unedited output.Opens: What are all six rules, and did they actually transform the host's work?Closes: The reason behind the 24-pencil ritual.
    0:40 –2:18Rules 1 & 2: Rapid Drafting and Pre-Writing LettersHow do you stop compulsive editing when your internal critic screams at every sentence?HoldEditing mid-draft kills flow; therefore, Steinbeck vented all his daily neuroses into private letters to his editor before touching his fiction.Opens: How does venting anxieties before writing affect daily word count?Closes: How Steinbeck bypassed the urge to rewrite early pages.
    2:18 –3:37Rule 3: One Page a Day & The Writing JournalCan writing just one page a day actually produce major novels like East of Eden?RiseFocusing on a 400-page book creates paralysis; therefore, Steinbeck logged only single working days to maintain sanity.Opens: Did Steinbeck ever conquer his severe imposter syndrome?Closes: The exact log format used to track daily effort.
    3:37 –5:16The Single Reader & Commercial FailureWhy does writing for a broad commercial audience lead to artistic and financial failure?RiseWriting for the faceless crowd freezes the author; therefore, targeting a single specific person unlocks honest prose, whereas Steinbeck's trend-chasing werewolf book failed miserably.Opens: What was the single most important lesson Steinbeck learned from his college professor?Closes: Why Steinbeck's werewolf novel 'Murder at Full Moon' was rejected.
    5:16 –7:05The One-Sentence Rule & Effective StorytellingHow do you know whether a sprawling story idea is actually worth pursuing?HoldNo technical rule guarantees good prose; therefore, a story only works if the writer can condense its moral core into a single clear sentence.Opens: What emergency trick did Steinbeck use when completely blocked?Closes: How Steinbeck formulated the central thesis of East of Eden.
    7:05 –8:31Unblocking with Throwaway PoetryWhat should a prose writer do when the words completely dry up?FallProse requires linear logic; therefore, writing throwaway poetry operates as mathematical therapy to unstick emotional blockages.Opens: What are the remaining practical editing rules?Closes: The advice Steinbeck gave playwright Bob Anderson to cure creative stagnation.
    8:31 –10:31Sponsor Segment & Background ResearchWill the video stall out entirely in a lengthy brand integration?FallSag: no turnOpens: When will the final rules be revealed?
    10:31 –12:21Rules 4, 5 & 6: Bypassing, Killing Darlings, Spoken DialogueWhat do you do when a favorite scene grinds the whole story to a halt?RiseStubborn scenes usually do not belong; therefore, bypassing them and reading spoken dialogue aloud exposes what is artificial.Opens: Does writing ever become effortless once you master these rules?Closes: Delivery of rules 4, 5, and 6.
    12:21 –13:49Rejection and Lifelong PersistenceDoes mastering Steinbeck's craft ever eliminate the pain of rejection?HoldDecades of success never made drafting easy; therefore, endurance and accepting imperfection are the only real answers.Closes: Steinbeck's lifelong struggle with rejection and the final verdict on his 6 rules.

    Payoff: delivered fully at 12:12. All six core writing rules and his tactile habits are fully explained and tested against the host's actual journaling routine by 12:12. Ending: A reflective conclusion citing Steinbeck's 1962 letter on enduring lifelong rejection, offering quiet artistic encouragement rather than pushing a hard call to action.

    Leaks

    Where a viewer might leave. Guesses from watching, not retention data.

    • 8:31 A hard cut into a two-minute Skillshare promotion detailing haiku classes breaks the narrative flow of Steinbeck's writing rules.
    • 9:32 The section on Steinbeck's local research in Salinas and England drifts away from actionable drafting habits into historical biographical trivia.

    Steal this

    1. Pair historical author quotes with overhead hands-on demonstrations of the exact physical constraint (e.g. 24 pencils, notebook letters). Grounding abstract craft advice in physical ritual makes intangible concepts feel practical and testable immediately. 0:22
    2. Validate the viewer's self-doubt by exposing the private failures and rejection letters of legendary icons. Showing that Steinbeck wrote a failed werewolf novel and confessed to feeling like an imposter lowers viewer intimidation and builds emotional rapport. 3:45
    3. Use kinetic aged-parchment quote graphics with highlighted key phrases to break up talking head delivery. Giving the viewer distinct visual primary sources provides proof and prevents visual fatigue during deep literary analysis. 4:02

    Skip this

    • Relying heavily on quiet, low-tempo acoustic piano music and static desk framing for nearly fourteen minutes. This works here because the bookish writing niche welcomes meditative study vibes, but in broader lifestyle or entertainment niches it causes severe audience drop-off.

    Open questions

    • What specific modern project was the creator working on while testing the 24-pencil method?
    • Did the host actually complete an entire manuscript using Steinbeck's rules, or only conduct short trial sessions?

    Teardown by Avail.video from the thumbnail, the title, the first 20 seconds and the report's notes on the whole video.

    On screen

    Everything the video showed you

    Slides, frameworks, quotes and formulas, captured verbatim with the moment they appeared. Tap any card to jump there.

    Reference shelf

    People, ideas and things mentioned

    Said means mentioned aloud; Shown means it appeared on screen.

    People10

    • John SteinbeckNobel and Pulitzer Prize-winning American novelist.0:00Said + shown0:44Said + shown2:32Said + shown4:00Said + shown4:20Said + shown4:56Said + shown5:39Said + shown6:44Said + shown7:43Said + shown10:39Said + shown12:07Said + shown12:38Said + shown
    • Edith Ronald MirrieleesStanford University professor and author of Story Writing who taught Steinbeck.5:19Said + shown12:38Said + shown13:03Said + shown
    • Pascal CoviciJohn Steinbeck's longtime editor and publisher at Viking Press.4:20Shown
    • Amasa MillerJohn Steinbeck's literary agent who received the Murder at Full Moon manuscript.5:04Shown
    • Peter PymJohn Steinbeck's pseudonym for his 1930 unpublished mystery werewolf novel.5:10Shown
    • Ernest HemingwayAmerican novelist and contemporary of Steinbeck.7:18Said + shown
    • Robert AndersonAmerican playwright advised by Steinbeck to write poetry to break writer's block.7:44Said
    • Robert WallstenAmerican writer, playwright, and correspondent of Steinbeck.7:38Shown
    • Thomas Malory15th-century English author of Le Morte d'Arthur.10:18Said
    • Stephen KingAmerican horror and suspense author.11:07Said

    Organizations1

    • SkillshareOnline learning platform offering creative writing courses.8:31Shown9:22Shown

    Things on screen6

    • East of Eden1952 magnum opus novel by John Steinbeck.0:10Said + shown6:44Said9:38Said11:41Said
    • The Grapes of Wrath1939 Pulitzer Prize-winning novel by John Steinbeck.0:12Shown
    • Tortilla FlatEarly novel by John Steinbeck rejected by numerous publishers.0:13Said + shown
    • The Red PonySteinbeck novel whose original manuscript was lost before being recreated.0:14Said + shown
    • Murder at Full MoonSteinbeck's unpublished 1930 werewolf mystery novel written under a pseudonym.0:14Shown4:50Said4:56Shown
    • Le Morte d'ArthurSir Thomas Malory's 15th-century compilation of Arthurian legends.10:16Shown10:18Said
    Video description

    A description you can paste into YouTube

    A hook, a summary, chapters in YouTube's format and what the video mentions. Copy it, edit it, and paste it into YouTube Studio.

    1,212 / 5,000 characters
    By the numbers

    What YouTube shows about this video and its channel

    As of Oct 30, 2026. YouTube's public numbers first, then Avail.video's own arithmetic on them.

    The video

    Views
    135K
    Likes
    2.5K
    Comments
    75
    Published
    Oct 20, 2026
    Length
    13:49
    Category
    Education
    YouTube's topics
    Lifestyle (sociology)
    Captions
    No
    HD
    Yes
    Language
    American English
    Paid promotion
    Declared
    Made for kids
    No
    License
    Standard YouTube

    Creator's tags

    No tags

    The channel

    Subscribers
    20.2K
    Videos
    15
    Total views
    1.7M
    Channel age
    3 years (since Nov 2022)
    Country
    —
    Uploads
    about every 7 weeks
    Across the last 13 long-form uploads
    Before this video
    79 days after the previous long-form upload

    Calculated by Avail.video from YouTube's public numbers

    Outlier score
    5.3× · Overperformer
    Views against the median of the channel's last 13 long-form uploads
    Views per subscriber
    6.68
    Likes vs the channel's usual
    0.4× the channel's usual
    1.9% of views vs a usual 5.2%
    Comments vs the channel's usual
    0.4× the channel's usual
    0.056% of views vs a usual 0.15%
    Rank among recent uploads
    #4 of 14
    By views: this video and the channel's last 13 long-form uploads
    Take it to your AI

    Ask Claude or ChatGPT about this video

    Copy this report as context, paste it into a chat, then ask anything. It includes timestamps, so answers can point back to the video.

    Then ask
    • Turn the main ideas into a checklist I can use this week.
    • What are the strongest claims in this video, and what evidence does it give for each?
    • Write a short summary for someone who hasn't watched it, linking the key moments.
    • Quiz me on this video, one question at a time, and cite the timestamp for each answer.

    Watched by Avail.video · 2026-10-30